How might the proposed DOL alternatives rule impact target date funds?
The overall direction of travel is a tailwind for alternative investments in target date strategies. The regulatory environment has moved from ambiguous to supportive, and there is now a clear, documented process a fiduciary can follow to establish prudence. That said, two specific elements of the proposal could shape product design and the way fees are communicated.
A. The first is liquidity considerations, particularly for collective investment trusts (CIT), which are not subject to the 40 Act’s liquidity risk management rules. The proposal offers an example in which a fiduciary is deemed prudent if the CIT operates a liquidity risk management program substantially similar to the one already required of open-end mutual funds. In practice, that framework would impose a 15% cap on illiquid investments. As drawn, the cap would apply at each individual vintage. This imposes a direct constraint on how much alternatives exposure a target date product can ultimately have — including for younger participants with longer time horizons for whom larger alternatives exposure might be appropriate. This is precisely why the final rule matters so much for the eventual design.
B. The second is the treatment of "carry," the performance fees charged by many alternative investment managers. Rather than passing those fees directly to participants, the proposal appears to favor a single all-in fee charged that would absorb “carry.” The goal is to make fees more predictable and easier for participants to understand by shifting the complexity and uncertainty of performance fees to the provider. A potential consequence is that providers may need to build those costs into their fee structures, which could result in higher or wider disclosed fee ranges.
What does the proposed DOL alternatives rule mean for litigation risk?
The guidance improves the legal landscape, but it does not create an absolute shield. What it does is establish a clear framework that, if followed, puts the plan fiduciary in a stronger position than one who simply adds alternative investments without a clear process. We expect the proposal to give many plan sponsors the comfort to move forward, though those with an especially conservative litigation posture or a higher litigation profile may still prefer to wait for case law to develop.
Will the proposed DOL alternatives rule survive a change in Administration?
A change in Administration or future DOL leadership is always a consideration, but it is important to separate regulatory uncertainty from the underlying investment case. Alternative investments have never been prohibited in DC plans, and the proposal does not create a new right to invest in them. Rather, it clarifies the fiduciary process for evaluating investments that include alternatives exposure and explicitly confirms there is no per se prohibition on their use.
Where do we see things heading?
Ultimately, the significance of the proposal lies less in any single provision than in the signal it sends. After years of hesitation, the DOL has articulated a path for fiduciaries to evaluate alternative investments within DC plans. The final rule will determine how much flexibility plan sponsors and target date providers ultimately have, but the broader trajectory appears clear: alternative investments are increasingly being viewed not as an exception requiring special justification, but as one of many tools fiduciaries may consider when seeking better outcomes for retirement savers.