Correction or Bear? Six Charts That Explain Market Declines
The market turmoil that began in early 2018 intensified later in the year, as the S&P 500 Index declined nearly 20% between its September peak and late December. This slide put U.S. equities firmly in correction territory — typically defined as a 10% drop from a recent high — and has raised questions about whether this could be the start of a much bigger setback.
But how often do corrections turn into entrenched bear markets? Not very often. In fact, there have already been six corrections since the current bull started in 2009.
There are countless reasons for short-term declines, but a prolonged bear market — a drop of at least 20% from a peak — usually results from severe economic imbalances that typically also lead to a recession. The current expansion’s slow recovery has delayed the onset of imbalances for years, but in recent months we have started to see some build, such as corporate debt. In the current environment, these issues don’t seem severe enough to cause a near-term recession, but they will require careful monitoring in the year ahead.
Below are five key points to keep in mind when thinking about market declines:
1. Corrections are fairly common.
Pullbacks happen more often than some may think. Even a 5% decline over a short period can feel unsettling, but they occur on average three times per year. Corrections of 10% or more are also surprisingly common and have happened on average once per year.
The volatility of early 2018 may have felt more jarring than usual because it followed a year that didn’t have a single 5% decline. But last year's volatility was much more typical than that of 2017. In fact, since 1980 there have been only four years without such a drawdown.
2. Markets typically have recovered quickly.
While markets may seem pessimistic during periods of heightened volatility, they often bounce back quickly. Despite averaging a double-digit correction per year, 31 of the last 41 calendar years have finished with positive returns.
Equity returns are often strongest after a decline when investors believe the market has overreacted. The average 12-month return immediately following a 15% or greater decline is 55%. That’s why it often can pay to remain calm and stay the course.
3. Bear markets have been rare outside of recessions.
Over the last 50 years, only eight of 36 corrections have been classified as bear markets. Most bears coincide with recessions, which are also relatively infrequent. In the absence of a recession, a growing economy can still spur positive corporate earnings growth, which supports equity prices. Market declines outside of recessions have tended to be shorter, and rebounded much quicker, than those during economic contractions.
Forecasting the start of the next recession is a difficult task, but it is fairly clear that the U.S. is in the later stages of an extended economic expansion. Recessions usually begin as a result of excesses in an overheating economy, and we are starting to see some early signs of this. Of note, corporate and government debt have been rising steadily. Shadow banking (unregulated financial transactions) is growing, and companies continue to take on debt to make dividend payments, implement share buybacks and fund M&A activity. The effects of tariffs on global trade and growth will also be worth monitoring in the year ahead.
At this time the imbalances don’t seem extreme enough to derail the economy in the near-term, but they do suggest weakness sometime in 2020, according to our economists. If monetary policy continues to ease, the ramifications of those imbalances could be pushed down the road.
4. Even bear markets have been relatively short-lived.
A long-term focus can help investors put bear markets into perspective. Since 1949, there have been nine periods of 20%-or-greater declines in the S&P 500. And while the average 33% drop can be painful, missing out on even part of the average bull market’s 263% return could be even worse.
Bear markets have averaged 14 months, a relatively short time compared with the 71 months of the average bull — another reason why trying to time investment decisions can be difficult and is usually ill-advised.
5. Volatility can compound investor mistakes.
Buy low and sell high — it’s one of the most commonly quoted investment phrases, but all too often it’s the opposite of how most investors behave. U.S. equity asset flows since the start of the 2008-09 bear market illustrate this.
In 2009, as markets bottomed to levels not seen in more than a decade, investors were net sellers. This continued even as markets rallied strongly over the next few years. It wasn’t until 2014 that investors became net buyers again after missing out on some of the best returns in years. Asset flows reached record levels in 2017 and 2018 — more than eight years into a bull market as share prices were reaching all-time highs and valuations were elevated.
Market declines can be painful to endure, but rather than trying to time the market, investors often are better served by periodically examining their holdings to ensure they are ready for elevated volatility. Investors should have a buffer of liquidity and sufficient diversification. During volatile periods, investors can benefit from:
- Maintaining a broadly-diversified portfolio
- Balancing between growth and dividend-oriented strategies within equities
- Ensuring their fixed income allocation provides diversification from equities
- Having a portion of their portfolio in liquid assets, such as cash and high-quality bonds
Posted January 16, 2019.