Capital Ideas

Investment insights from Capital Group

Active Management
When markets turn down, active managers have often held up

This article was originally published June 7, 2016.

Funds with certain characteristics have, on average, tended to generate better results during market turbulence.

As in years past, the early days of 2016 found many in the investing community awaiting confirmation of a seemingly unimpeachable truth: the average active manager had once again failed to beat the index.

To their surprise, that confirmation has not been forthcoming.

That’s because, in a year when markets sputtered and tumbled on concerns about China’s future and sinking oil prices, the Wall Street Journal reported that in 2015, actively managed open-ended funds tracked by Morningstar Inc. actually did better than their passive counterparts, losing an average of 2.2% compared to a 2.7% loss for passive funds.

It’s a small difference, to be sure — but it illustrates the potential benefits of active management, particularly in down markets. “In challenging markets, active managers have tended to do better,” says Rob Lovelace, Vice-chairman and an equity portfolio manager at Capital Group.

“Solid stock selection can prove its mettle, and the cash in portfolios acts as a cushion. Not to mention the fact that during downturns active managers can invest opportunistically, which can support long-term results,” Lovelace says.

Despite the potential for actively managed funds to add resilience to portfolios, many investors continue to view passive options as a safer choice. A common argument is that, with index funds, they get a certain peace of mind that their portfolios will only drop as far as the index does — eliminating the regrets that can come with trailing a benchmark.

But committing to the market return can have its drawbacks. Full exposure to market downturns adds stress to the portfolios of retirees and those taking income — a risk they may not fully grasp. In a recent survey conducted by opinion research firm APCO Insight, 78% of retirees said that protecting savings and investment gains from market downturns is an important priority. Yet only 53% are aware that investing in index funds exposes them to all the ups and downs of the market.

The all-index-fund path also boxes out actively managed funds with a history of holding up better during downturns, and it fails to account for the fact that such resilience — in combination with other factors — has been instrumental in the return calculus of funds with long-term track records of beating their benchmarks.

Funds with low downside capture histories fared well during declines.

An analysis of large-cap U.S. funds over the past four decades shows how those with a history of low downside capture have done better than those without a similar history during the worst market downturns. Downside capture ratio compares a fund’s return with an index’s during periods when the index return was negative. In other words, a lower downside capture ratio indicates that the fund did better in declining markets.

A review of monthly rolling five-year periods in that four-decade time frame shows that, during the market’s 50 worst rolling five-year periods, the quartile of funds with the best downside capture characteristics going into those periods had better results than those of the other quartiles. In those periods, the funds in the best downside capture quartile generated better results than the worst downside capture funds by an average of more than 1.5% annually. Top-quartile funds also fared well across other metrics, including standard deviation, beta and maximum drawdown.

Downside capture ratio compares a fund’s return with an index’s during periods when the index return was negative. In other words, a lower downside capture ratio indicates that the fund did better in declining markets.

Low downside capture is not enough.

Importantly, the same study revealed that the lowest downside capture quartile did not outpace the broader market, based on the average for all the periods measured. There are, however, other fund characteristics associated with index-beating outcomes, according to recent research by Capital Group.

The study found that over the last 20 years, a group of actively managed equity funds with lower-than-average downside capture and low expense ratios whose managers were heavily invested in the funds they managed, on average, outpaced their respective benchmark indexes. That was true over five- and 10-year time frames as well.

This group of actively managed funds was, on average, able to generate index-beating results during particularly tough times: The test period included the dot-com meltdown in 2000 and the 2008 financial crisis.

“In a common withdrawal scenario, the group generated measurably better results than both the index and the entire active universe by nearly 150 basis points annually, which over the course of a normal retirement can be the difference between success and failure,” says Steve Deschenes, a research and development director at Capital Group.  Even as withdrawals increased in retirement scenarios, this select group of active funds outpaced their benchmarks and peers.

“There’s no reason to settle for average, Deschenes says. "There’s an opportunity to do better — and substantially better — to create more wealth.”

Past results are not predictive of results in future periods.

Investing outside the United States involves risks, such as currency fluctuations, periods of illiquidity and price volatility, as more fully described in the prospectus. These risks may be heightened in connection with investments in developing countries.

Hear from the investment team.

Don't miss out

Get the Capital Ideas newsletter in your inbox each week


Investments are not FDIC-insured, nor are they deposits of or guaranteed by a bank or any other entity, so they may lose value.

Investors should carefully consider investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses. This and other important information is contained in the fund prospectuses and summary prospectuses, which can be obtained from a financial professional and should be read carefully before investing.

All Capital Group trademarks mentioned are owned by The Capital Group Companies, Inc., an affiliated company or fund. All other company and product names mentioned are the property of their respective companies.

Use of this website is intended for U.S. residents only.

American Funds Distributors, Inc., member FINRA.

This content, developed by Capital Group, home of American Funds, should not be used as a primary basis for investment decisions and is not intended to serve as impartial investment or fiduciary advice.

Statements attributed to an individual represent the opinions of that individual as of the date published and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Capital Group or its affiliates. This information is intended to highlight issues and should not be considered advice, an endorsement or a recommendation.